Welcome to Mellow Mushroom New Albany
Mellow Mushroom New Albany invites guests into a vibrant and eclectic atmosphere where pizza reigns supreme. This popular eatery in New Albany, OH, is celebrated not just for its extensive pizza offerings, which include options tailored for vegan and vegetarian diets, but also for its casual, family-friendly vibe. Signature dishes like the Magic Mushroom Soup and the Meatball Trio showcase their commitment to quality and creativity. With outdoor seating and a full bar, Mellow Mushroom is ideal for any occasion—from lively dinners to casual lunches. Patrons rave about the attentive service and a quirky ambiance that promises a unique dining experience.
-
260 Market St Ste A New Albany, OH 43054 United States Hotline: (614) 245-4234
Welcome to Mellow Mushroom New Albany, where a vibrant atmosphere meets a diverse menu filled with flavor-packed dishes! Nestled at 260 Market St Ste A, New Albany, OH 43054, this eclectic eatery offers an inviting space for families, groups of friends, and casual diners alike. With its unique decor and lively vibe, Mellow Mushroom transforms dining into a memorable experience.
As a food reviewer and culinary enthusiast, I can’t help but share the highlights that make this restaurant a must-visit. Mellow Mushroom specializes in not just pizza, but also bar bites and hearty sandwiches. The menu caters to varied dietary preferences, with plenty of vegan and vegetarian options to satisfy every palate. Who says pizza can't be inclusive?
- Signature Pizzas: Mellow Mushroom is renowned for its creative and delicious pizzas. The dough is made with care, resulting in a light and fluffy crust that's perfect for holding an abundance of fresh toppings. Diners rave about the Magic Mushroom Soup Bowl and their acclaimed Meatball Trio, which tantalize taste buds with rich flavors and quality ingredients.
- Appetizers and Salads: For those starting their meals, options like Spinach Artichoke Dip and Bruschetta are crowd favorites. Furthermore, the salad selection, such as the Enlightened Spinach Salad, allows for customization, ensuring that you get a plate tailored to your liking.
- Nutty Experience for Everyone: Dining with your canine companions? Mellow Mushroom has dog-friendly patio seating! This friendly approach, coupled with attentive service, makes it an enjoyable outing for both pets and their owners.
- Happy Hour Buzz: If you're looking for a good time, visit on a Thursday, Friday, or Saturday during happy hours to indulge in special drink deals while enjoying the lively ambiance.
The reviews speak volumes about the establishment's dedication to providing a great dining experience. Many patrons express their admiration for the attentive staff and the restaurant’s cleanliness, which enhances the overall visit. The eclectic decor adds an artistic flair, making it a perfect backdrop for dining or even dancing during special nights. Family-friendly, the restaurant offers options that appeal to kids, making it an ideal choice for family dinners.
In essence, Mellow Mushroom New Albany combines culinary creativity with a relaxed setting, making it a delightful destination for pizza lovers and food adventurers alike. Whether you’re here for a hearty meal or a fun night out, the flavors and atmosphere are sure to leave you satisfied. So, grab your friends or family, and prepare for a pizza experience that raises the bar!
It's so easy to make a good house salad with fresh crisp greens, but unfortunately Mellow Mushroom covered the brown lettuce with cheese and toppings maybe hoping we wouldn't see the soggy, not so fresh lettuce underneath. Threw out half of a $12.00 salad. Love their pizza but wish they could be as consistent with all of the menu items.
The pizza was really good, the service was good, the restaurant was pretty clean. I really can't say anything bad about this place. The pizza was really good!
We love their Vegan cheese pizza it's our favorite. It's a great option for being dairy free.
Easily the best pizza chain in Columbus! Their pizzas always come out hot, fresh, and loaded with toppings--full of flavor in every bite. The menu offers a great variety beyond just pizza, with plenty of appetizers and salads to choose from. Service was attentive, and they have a solid drink menu to round out the meal. Ambience was quirky and lively, but also a good lunch spot with good deals! A go-to spot for a consistently great dining experience!
Cool atmosphere!! I thought there would be more trippy decor but still dope! Food was great! And I loved the menus! The service was amazing! They a made sure we had drinks when they'd go half empty and made sure we were taken care of! Bathrooms were cool I liked the door handle!
Haven't dined at a Mellow Mushroom for a long time. This trip in we decided to do something different, we brought our dogs. Having two small dogs we decided to seat ourselves on the patio. Leaving dogs with my husband I went inside to let them know we sat ourselves, inform them we had two dogs with us and see if this was all okay. It was received very well by the staff. Hostess gathered menus and I showed her where we were The patio is narrow. Single row of tables wrap in an L shaped pattern. We were one of two tables in the front vs more along the side of the building. Zoe, our server soon came out. We discussed pizzas and learned they could make my favorite pizza even though it is no longer on the menu... however we decided to go with a modified current one. It was delicious. The crust is whole wheat salt water based... so you feel as if the choice to eat pizza is a bit more healthy. However the dough is billowy and not edge to edge so it has nice crust. They used a LOT of cheese which is a plus for taste but not for health... but this is pizza--- you really dont order that as a "healthy choice". We added the mushroom trio... there could of been a bit more of that for the upcharge but Id say there was a fair amount on the pizza. Zoe checked on us regularly and made our dogs comfortable by bringing them water and giving them praise and fuss. The pizza came out quickly which was nice as it started out pretty hot on the patio and the dogs weren't digging the heat. These dogs appreciate that always! The pizza was delicious. Cooked perfectly and left full and with half the pizza boxed nicely. All together it was an excellent trip in. Thank you staff of Mellow Mushroom for a great evening on your patio! Pizza was great!
My son, grandson & I went there for father's day with 3 others and it totally exceeded expectations. Amazingly, they weren't very busy at midafternoon but we had an awesome server. We had a mighty meaty and a great white pizzas. Both were very delicious & we pretty much devoured them. We think the atmosphere was "movie themed," but regardless, it was quite nice. Wish we had on near Beavercreek.
I ordered the pacific rim specialty pizza on gluten free crust. The gluten free pizza only comes in a small so that's what I got. I omitted the jalapeños, which left mozzarella,ham, bacon, pineapple and caramelized onions. It was great! The next time I will definitely have them toast it more but I cannot complain at all.
It's good pizza! I ordered the Koranic Karma, we also ordered a couple build your own pizzas. It's a solid, descent pizza. Way better then the local Eagle Villa Pizza. The inside is very eclectic, youthful and artsy. As for our server, he was good but very sassy.